Talking to parents about nontraditional grading practices

“Q: “How can I help parents understand my nontraditional grading and assessment practices? I’m getting so much pushback this year that I’m considering going back to the old way because it feels like it might be easier. Can you please help? A: If I had a dollar for every time a parent (or colleague) pushed back about the innovations I introduced in the classroom years ago, I’d be rich. The pushback you are feeling can be exhausting. When you put time and thought into nontraditional grading practices — whether that means standards-based grading, reassessment, no zeros, separating behavior from academic achievement, or offering more feedback and revision — it can be discouraging when families respond with confusion or frustration . The fact is that parents are advocating for a system they understand, which is the one they lived through. This new paradigm doesn’t make sense to them right away, so they object. If you are considering going back to the old way because it feels easier, you wouldn’t be the first teacher to do that. But “easier” in the short term is usually not better for students in the long term. The goal is not to win every parent over immediately. It is to help families understand what you are doing, why you are doing it, and how it supports student learning, regardless of their struggles with the shift. Start With the Why One of the biggest mistakes schools and teachers make in addressing parental concerns is leading with the system instead of the purpose. Parents do not usually wake up wondering about grading structures. They wake up wondering: Is my child doing OK? How will I know if they are learning? Will this help or hurt my child’s grade, GPA, or college readiness? So before you explain the technical details of your grading practice, start with the bigger picture. Parents want to know that what you are doing is in the best interest of their child, so lead with why. You might say: “My goal is to make sure grades reflect what students actually know and can do, not just whether they turned something in on time or completed a first draft.” That simple framing helps parents understand that your system is not about making grading harder. It is about making it more honest and more useful. Acknowledge the Concern Before Defending the Practice It is tempting to jump immediately into explanation mode when parents are skeptical. But parents often need to feel heard before they are willing to listen. I found myself doing this a lot when I first started to make some big shifts. I sometimes alienated students and parents in my quest to make them understand. Try acknowledging their concerns directly by listening and then saying: “I understand why this feels different.” “I know this grading system may look unfamiliar.” “I hear your concern about fairness and consistency.” “It makes sense to want clear answers about how your child is doing.” When parents feel respected, they are more likely to stay engaged. If they feel dismissed, they will often dig in harder. Truly validate concerns without being defensive. Make the System Visible and Simple Nontraditional grading becomes much easier to understand when it is not presented using educator jargon. Avoid terms that sound vague or overly theoretical. Instead, use plain language. For example, if you use reassessment, tell parents: “Students have the chance to show improved understanding after feedback. This means learning is not being graded after a first try.” If you separate behaviors from academics , explain: “A missing assignment may affect completion or work habits, but it should not automatically distort the grade for content mastery. So instead of penalizing a grade, we are going to figure out why the work wasn’t completed.” If you use standards-based grading , say: “Students are assessed on specific learning targets so we can see exactly what they know, what they are still learning, and what support they need next.” Parents do not need a dissertation. They need clarity and simplicity. Show What the Grade Means In my experience, a major source of parent frustration is the feeling that grades have become less transparent. I used to share with my families that they are actually getting more specific information now. I assured them that the feedback would be easy to understand and, more importantly, that their child would be able to explain to them how they are doing. I promised transparency and welcomed their comments and questions. I also learned that the more explicit you can be, the better. A simple rubric, scoring guide, or sample student work can go a long way in helping families understand how to interpret the system. Communicate Before There Is a Problem Each school year, I sent a letter home to parents explaining how grading in my classes would be different. I made a screencast that explained how my dashboard looked and how to interpret what they saw. I also invited them to be curious. If parents only hear from you when they are confused about a grade, the conversation starts in a defensive place. Parents need to be forewarned, not mitigated. Sharing the necessary info throughout the process will help make communication easier. If possible, make sure to communicate in phases and even if you don’t get feedback along the way, keep sharing updates. If you share things in segments, it won’t get overwhelming. Additionally, when you share specific information about their child, make sure to use concrete examples. Invite Questions, But Set Boundaries You do not have to absorb every complaint as if you need to apologize for your approach. You do, however, need to create space for questions. You might say: “I know this is a shift, and I welcome questions because I want families to understand how this supports student learning.” At the same time, you are not required to rethink every decision with every parent. If your practices are aligned to school expectations, standards, or a researched approach, stand confidently in that work. Parents may not need to agree immediately, but you’ll gain their support if you are thoughtful, consistent, and student-centered. Remember that pushback does not automatically mean your practice is wrong. Sometimes it means the communication is incomplete or misleading. Sometimes it means the change is hard. Sometimes it means families are comparing your class to the grading system they experienced as students. That does not mean you should ignore their concerns. It means you should respond with more clarity, not necessarily retreat. Ask yourself: Have I explained the purpose clearly? Share your purpose with a colleague or friend for feedback. Have I shown what this looks like in practice? Perhaps you need to document the work to share or provide examples to families that make it real. Have I answered the common questions before they became complaints? Consider sharing an FAQ with parents or posting it to your class website. Have I helped families see how this benefits their child? If the answer is no to any of these questions, you may need to step up communications, not return to the old system. Non-traditional grading can be a powerful step toward more meaningful assessment, but it rarely succeeds without strong communication. Parents do not need perfect language or a polished slogan. They need honesty, transparency, and evidence that your approach is grounded in student learning. There were many points along the way I wanted to give up because of challenges created by folks who didn’t understand why we were doing what we were doing. It felt overwhelming, but I worked hard to keep the focus on the students and how I knew this was better for them. Give the families time, and they will see it too. If you have an issue that you would like me to address, please email me at ssackstein@educatorsrising.org or complete this form . You will be kept anonymous. The post Talking to parents about nontraditional grading practices appeared first on Kappan Online .

Summary generated from the RSS feed of Phi Delta Kappan. All article rights belong to the original publisher. Click through to read the full piece on kappanonline.org.